Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

More from DeviantArt


Submitted on
May 25, 2012
Submitted with Writer


3 (who?)

Dear Archie co.,



 I'm sorry to say this,but I am growing dissapointment at your Sonic comics.It is utterly ruining the fanbase,and causing mast confusion.I think it's really best to either do a reboot,or just give up the comics in general.Personally,I would go with the reboot.It is best to help many fans,who are losing faith in the comic.Many fans are having constant rants either at Ian,other fans,or you.


See,the main problem is probally the plot-holes.There seems to be constant errors in most of your writing.For example,Mobius X.When you made Shadow took over Acorn and did all that,you forgot Shadow's promise.Also,another example is how a doctor told Bunnie her legs would never be normal again,but you went ahead and made that way again


Other complaints are explained below.


The Out Of Charactering

Constant times,characters do this and that,despite what they would normally do.Remember Tails was yelling at Sonic,Sonic,his long time friend for a girl?Since when Tails would fight his friend over a girl?



Many Satam fans love how you brung back this famous character.They really appriceated it.However you made her the most blantant sue in the series.All the boyfriends,the friends.She's a sue.And it's best if you fixed it right away,since it's the second main problem.
The main subject is,it's time for a reboot.Please don't fire anyone,but at least change the comic a bit.Hiring new writers would probaly help as well.



Might edit later...There's so many problems...That it's hard to fit this when you had a long day at shcool

A new submition for Archie.
Add a Comment:
swe191 Featured By Owner Feb 9, 2013
silver is the only character that archie got right
every one else is out of character
cartoonking1 Featured By Owner May 28, 2012
I respect your opinion and by all means hate the book but it is not ruining the fanbase, the fanbase has been at each other’s throats for ages and will continue to be, I mean the fandom still argues about his eye color, fans do not have to like every Sonic Continuity, they do not have to even acknowledge the other Continuity’s but what is needed is respecting that everyone has their “own Sonic”, if people have such a problem with the Archie comics they can just ignore them, not acknowledge them and find some you like to fill its place or write your own versions because even thought you and others like may not like it there just as many that like it just the way it is.

Mobius X-Years latter is a what if tale in a possible future, certain thing happened to Shadow in that time line that lead to Shadow becoming a tyrant which was his way of keeping his promise to Mira by keeping a tight grip on Mobius he can all ways protected and punish those he deems evil. So Shadow is still keeping his promise just in a slightly slanted way, not the best way but it is the way Shadow chose in this world.

There are a multitude of reasons that Bunnie got her original limbs back, the Genesis wave that reset the world, The Chaos Emerald which has a great deal of power, Nagus’s magical abilities (he turned Robotnik’s head into a crow and a pig so restoring Bunnies limbs is not that much of a stretch and then add the fact that Nagus did it completely by accident so who knows how long it will last of if Bunnie will suffer any side effects.

Characters can have different sides to themselves, seeing then out of there set traits is what makes them interesting. Tails is allowed to get angry, Tails had a big crush on Fiona and Sonic dated her despite knowing how Tails felt and did to apologize until much later. After they got that incident behind them they have never been closer and never fought like that again.

The term “Mary-sue” is very vague, so what if Sally had a lot of boyfriends, Sonic has had more love interest that her, Peter Parker had a lot of girlfriends until he married Mary Jane, Bruce Wayne has lost of love interest as well that does not make them Mary-sues.
Like I said you can hate the comics but if you have such a problem with them

I would not acknowledge them at all, have a nice day.
SonTaliaFan666 Featured By Owner May 29, 2012  Student Writer
I don't really read it anymore.In fact,I threw out all my comics.I thought the characters were already whiney.

Also,on your Bunnie thing.If genesis reset the world?Why didn't her legs been gone?Also,why didn't everyone turn into way past selves,if they reseted the world?Everything would've turn into old days if was reseted.

In SEGA also,Sonic only had a few.When Archie came,a bunch sprang up.

Thanks for respecting my opinion though,I appreciate it. :D
cartoonking1 Featured By Owner May 29, 2012
Well good for you, I hope you find something else to take its place.

I said that the Genesis wave might have contributed to Bunnies turning back to normal not that is was the main cause.

You will get quite a few characters if a comic continues for two-hundred issues, not to mention we only focus on them when the story calls for it.

You are welcome my friend, you have the right to enjoy what you want and I have a right to enjoy what I want, spread the respect around.
LaviArray Featured By Owner May 25, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Completely agree, but I must add:

1. No more romance
Having this as a sub-plot just adds unnecessary melodrama that is not needed. Let the story be the drama.

2. Flesh out your characters
Too many of the cast members are under developed. I've heard you cant touch the game characters, but could you the characters you already have?
HallowpointPaws Featured By Owner May 25, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
shirinuigod Featured By Owner May 25, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Don't forget they put the canon characters in the background =3=

nice letter~
smt1822 Featured By Owner May 25, 2012
This letter is dead on! I like every Sonic continuity, but I'll admit that stuff like this has ruined this fandom. All the fights about canon, couples, what have you. If they need a reboot, I have one in mind that'd make EVERY fan, old and new, happy. But... chances of that are pretty slim.
jakeroo123 Featured By Owner May 25, 2012
It's especially out of character with how Tails is in the old TV Shows, one of which Archie comics are supposed to be based off of directly... Both in his relationship with Sonic and his (low) opinion of romance.
FunnelVortex Featured By Owner May 26, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
Tails' character wasnt developed yet at the time.

But he has been shown to be a mechanical genius in AoSTH, and fly planes as well.
Add a Comment: